Sorry, you need to enable JavaScript to visit this website.

War’s long half-life

Photographs of the aftermath at Tate Modern

Simon Willis | November 28th 2014

“Conflict, Time, Photography”, which has just opened at Tate Modern, begins shortly after a big bang. On the wall as you go in, there’s a large photo of rural Afghanistan by Luc Delahaye, with flat dry fields, low mud buildings and mountains in the background. In the middle of the picture a cloud from an explosion hangs in the air: an American bomb dropped on Taliban positions. The explosion itself is dispersing and the scene is recovering its calm. As in every picture in the exhibition, something violent has already happened. This isn’t a show about the clamour and crash of war itself, but the atmospheric disturbances and deafening silences that follow.

As you move through the rooms, that silence becomes more and more insidious. The show is organised chronologically, although not in the usual sense. With each room, the photographs are separated from the events they relate to by longer and longer stretches of time. At first it is a matter of seconds. Delahaye is joined at the beginning by Toshio Fukada, who captured the mushroom cloud blasting into the sky at Hiroshima in 1945. Seconds then turn into minutes, with Don McCullin's famous portrait of the American marine in Vietnam with the thousand-yard stare, frozen by what's just happened. Minutes then become months, months become years, and by the time we get to Chloe Dewe Mathews' photographs at the end we're looking back a whole century. Her subjects are fields and woodland in Flanders on hushed winter mornings, at the exact spots where soldiers were executed for cowardice during the first world war—a suite of chilling memorials. 

Mathews' pictures show us the aftermath as a series of grim particulars, where the precondition for remembering is knowing exactly what happened, to whom, where and when. You see it too in Taryn Simon's piece about the massacre at Srebenica in 1995, which is full of rigour and restraint. In a large frame she has arranged photographs of people from the same blood line alongside the evidence of lost lives: portraits of an old man and woman, and then photos of a small skeleton, a single tooth and a shard of bone—the remains of their men and boys sifted from the grave. Elsewhere even less is left over. A set of pictures taken in the Eighties and Nineties by Hiromi Tsuchida show simple objects from Hiroshima. There's a metal lunch box with carbonised peas and rice still inside, a torn jacket, a small glass lens. The belongings remained, the bodies did not.

Fragments, though, aren't just subjects; they are organising principles. In room after room you see photographers working with large collections of images gathered into one work, which gives you a feeling for the sheer extent of the damage, of obsessive retrospection and of brokenness. The French photographer Sophie Ristelhueber, who gets a room to herself, went to Iraq in the months after the first Gulf war for her project "Fait" (1991), which mixes aerial shots of tank tracks in the sand and burning oil fields with close-ups of used ordnance, broken boots and the remains of blown-up vehicles—debris great and small wherever you look. In Diana Matar's series about Libya after the fall of Qaddafi, the power comes from what you can't see or what remains hidden. There's the causeway that led to the torture chambers in Benghazi—presumably behind the faceless concrete doorways—and a simple shot of the Mediterranean, into which Qadaffi's henchmen threw powdered bones. They are pictures with a searching sense of violence which has been secreted away.

In the end, what is most potent is the idea of war's long half-life. Often that is horribly literal: the bodily scars on the faces of burned men and women photographed decades after the bombing of Nagasaki, or the white-eyed faces of blind children in Hiroshima. We see the architectural scars, too, like the wide open wounds in Berlin shot in 1980 by Michael Schmidt. But what the exhibition gives off most powerfully is the stink of war as a pollutant which can hang for decades over a stretch of water or a tranquil grove of trees, radiating unease.

Conflict, Time, Photography Tate Modern, London, to March 15th

3 Readers' comments

Sign in or Create your account to join the discussion.

Roarperdeno - June 4th 2017

Я, Бурдиез (Бурнусузян) Сергей Владимирович- великий учитель, убиваю детей, стариков, женщин по фотографии дистанционно. Телепортирую ледяной шарик даже в сердце президенту дистанционно. Сделаю инсульт любому по фото. Бросаю вызов магам, ведьмам, колдунам, уничтожу любого мага. Как пример моей работы колдуна Фата завалил я. Ищу учеников, для обучения дистанционного убийства политической верхушки России. Растягивая и сжимая время могу убрать человека. Обучение проходит в г. Москва, ул. Причальный проезд д.8 Мой профиль вконтакте tel +7-915-05-111-50

AlenaHip - June 1st 2017

<img></img> <b>Год издания</b>: 2016 <b>Автор</b>: Рибчинський О.Г. <b>Жанр или тематика</b>: Роман <b>Издательство</b>: Афіша <b>ISBN</b>: 978-966-325-224-7 <b>Язык</b>: Украинский <b>Формат</b>: PDF <b>Качество</b>: Издательский макет или текст (eBook) <b>Количество страниц</b>: 454 <b>Описание</b>: Женщина, изменяя мужу, получает удовольствие. Ему же достается этот грех, невыносимая боль унижения его мужского достоинства. Желание избавиться от него, человек творит подвиги чтобы утолить, забыть этот грех, подняться над ним. Но напрасно: вся его жизнь горчит тем грехом и все его старания и подвиги тонут в слащавом греху женской измены. Такой сюжет романа «Сладкий грех, или анатомия измены». Это вторая книга Львовского автора Олега Рыбчинского и она является продолжением любовно-исторического романа «Черные морели». События и герои реальные, только из морально-этических соображений их имена изменены. <a href=><IMG></IMG></a> <a href=><IMG></IMG></a> <a href=><IMG></IMG></a> <a href=>Скачать</a>

NaskaGat - May 28th 2017

Two bitches dressed as nuns start a kinky game, that involves playing with electrodes. See lovely Sophia Locke laying in bed. After a passionate kiss, her sensual mouth is gagged and her legs are tied up, while her appetizing buttocks get spanked by merciless Mia Li. Enjoy the sexy scenario! A pair of soft natural breasts can make a guy feel good. Alison has such boobs and she knows how to rub that dick with them after sucking it. She squeezes the hard penis between them and then continues the sucking. What do you think about her, can she handle it in her tight pussy the same way she did with her boobs? She's white, huge and blonde. Meet our chunky bitch Trashly, a splendid bbw with golden hair and pony tails. Trashly feels attracted by her muscled trainer and she wants to suck his cock more than anything. This time the bitch got what she wanted, so he grabbed her by those ponytails and mouth fucked her. This fellow was at his friend's house when the sexy blonde mom next door approached him to see if he wanted to fuck. Of course he said yes and pretty soon she's naked and sucking his cock. Then she diddles herself while eating out his hairy ass. With a pair of legs like that it's hard not to be under her control. Straight from Ukraine here's Nika and her ways of dominating men. This lucky guy has the honor of being under her high heels and to lick her shaved sweet cunt. Like it until now? Then stick around because this Ukrainian natural beauty has a lot more Yeah, it's like a piece of art and this artist knows it! Syren has a gorgeous booty and the guy wants to see it framed but he also wants to fuck it. By combining art and dirty fucking, he succeeds in making a real masterpiece with her booty and his big hard cock. This is the perfect example of ass art! She is outdoors enjoying nature and looking sexy as usual. The Indian hottie shows off her sexy body and outfit, as she poses by the cliffs. Watch as she lifts up her skirt and shows off her cute cotton panties, before pulling them down and showing off her very cute butt. She pulls her cock out in the yard and masturbates to get herself nice and hard. Then she heads over to her man kneels down and suck on his rock hard pecker. He strokes off as she sucks on his balls and then she jerks off her cock, too. My elect free sex pics sites QLpu9H8RcJKn7eBf2v3a040C